Objective: The debate over potential adverse effects of cervical spine manipulation, particularly its association with vertebrobasilar artery stroke, intensified within the chiropractic profession during the 1990s and early 21st century. Far less attention has been paid to the Founder’s own early instructional practices concerning the cervical spine.
In Fight to Climb (1950), B.J. Palmer claimed that DD Palmer deliberately avoided teaching neck adjustments to early students because he had absorbed orthodox medicine’s warnings about the dangers of cervical work. By contrast, DD Palmer’s 1910 text The Chiropractor’s Adjuster consistently describes the first chiropractic adjustment (performed on Harvey Lillard in 1895) as occurring at the fourth dorsal vertebra and portrays his clinical development as a methodical progression from dorsal to lumbar to lower cervical regions, with Atlas work introduced last.
This paper analyzes the divergence between these primary accounts and evaluates whether DD Palmer’s early restraint reflected primarily political expediency or clinically grounded prudence. Engagement with original sources offers a more nuanced understanding of chiropractic’s foundational period and underscores the value of primary-source scholarship in professional historiography.
Author Keywords: Chiropractic history, DD Palmer, B.J. Palmer, Harvey Lillard, Cervical Spine Manipulation, Primary Sources, Historiography
This abstract is reproduced with the permission of the publisher. Click on the above link for free full text.
|